Robin Hartill, CFP®, is The Ascent’s Head of Product Ratings and has worked for The Motley Fool since 2020. Her work has appeared in various national publications, including Yahoo! Finance, NerdWallet, Investopedia, CNN Underscored, MSNBC, USA Today, and CNET Money. She previously wrote The Penny Hoarder’s syndicated “Dear Penny” personal finance advice column. She is based in St. Petersburg, Florida.
Our Insurance Expert
Fact Checked Ashley Maready Writer and EditorAshley Maready is a former history museum professional who made the leap to digital content writing and editing in 2021. She has a BA in History and Philosophy from Hood College and an MA in Applied History from Shippensburg University. Ashley loves creating content for the public and learning new things so she can teach others, whether it's information about salt mining, canal mules, or personal finance.
Many or all of the products here are from our partners that compensate us. It’s how we make money. But our editorial integrity ensures our experts’ opinions aren’t influenced by compensation. Terms may apply to offers listed on this page.
Bottom line: USAA generally has cheaper rates than Progressive, but membership is limited to military members, veterans, and their family members.
Our ratings are based on a 5 star scale. 5 stars equals Best. 4 stars equals Excellent. 3 stars equals Good. 2 stars equals Fair. 1 star equals Poor. We want your money to work harder for you. Which is why our ratings are biased toward offers that deliver versatility while cutting out-of-pocket costs.
= Best
= Excellent
= Good
= Fair
= Poor
Our ratings are based on a 5 star scale. 5 stars equals Best. 4 stars equals Excellent. 3 stars equals Good. 2 stars equals Fair. 1 star equals Poor. We want your money to work harder for you. Which is why our ratings are biased toward offers that deliver versatility while cutting out-of-pocket costs.
= Best
= Excellent
= Good
= Fair
= Poor
USAA generally has cheaper car insurance rates than Progressive, however, USAA membership is limited to current and former military members and their families. Keep in mind, though, that many factors influence your car insurance rates, including your ZIP code, age, driving history, vehicle, and credit history.
| Type of Driver | Which Is Cheaper? | Progressive | USAA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clean driving record | USAA | $2,104 | $1,656 |
| 18-year-old new driver | USAA | $6,314 | $4,348 |
| Drivers with a speeding ticket | USAA | $2,576 | $2,012 |
| Drivers with a DUI | Progressive | $2,535 | $3,067 |
| Drivers with poor credit | USAA | $3,483 | $2,848 |
Like other top car insurance companies, both Progressive and USAA offer standard types of auto insurance coverage, including:
Each company also provides common add-on coverages, like rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, and umbrella insurance.
Progressive also offers powersports insurance for vehicles like RVs/motorhomes, boats, motorcycles, electronic bikes, and ATVs/UTVs. USAA actually offers these types of coverage through an alliance with Progressive. USAA members can buy these policies at a 5% discount, but Progressive is the insurer.
Both companies are leading rideshare driver insurance companies, though USAA doesn't offer this coverage in Hawaii, North Carolina, Michigan, Montana, New Mexico, New York, South Carolina, or Virginia.
Each insurer has a few unique types of coverage. For example, Progressive automatically provides pet injury coverage when you include collision insurance on your policy. If your pet gets injured while riding in your vehicle, up to $1,000 of their vet bills will be covered. If you're a USAA member with comprehensive and collision insurance, you can add car replacement assistance to your policy, which provides up to 20% over your car's cash value if it's totaled or stolen.
Both Progressive and USAA offer multiple types of discounts. Many of these discounts are fairly standard, like good student discounts and discounts for bundling multiple types of policies, e.g., auto insurance and homeowner insurance.
Each insurer also allows you to earn personalized rates based on your behavior if you agree to let a telematics device monitor your driving activity: USAA through its SafePilot app and Progressive through its Snapshot app or plug-in device. USAA says you can save up to 30% with SafePilot, and participation will never increase your premiums. While Progressive says the average driver saves about $231 through Snapshot, about 20% of drivers see their rates increase.
Not surprisingly, USAA has a couple of discounts tailored to military families: Members who are deployed or are storing an insured vehicle for another reason can save up to 60%. If you garage your car on a military base, you can also save up to 15%.
| Type of discount | Progressive | USAA |
|---|---|---|
| Anti-theft discount | Yes | Yes |
| Continuous coverage | Yes | No |
| Good student discount | Yes | Yes |
| Homeowner | Yes | No |
| Low mileage discount | No | Yes |
| Multicar | Yes | Yes |
| Multipolicy | Yes | Yes |
| New vehicle | No | Yes |
| Online quote and sign | Yes | No |
| Pay in full | Yes | No |
| Safe driver discount | Yes | Yes |
Most of us buy car insurance with the goal of never having to use it. Both Progressive and USAA have a network of pre-approved repair shops that you can take your car to if you're involved in a collision. While using a shop within each company's network can streamline the repair process, the law generally prohibits insurers from requiring you to use a specific shop.
You can initiate Progressive's claims process by logging into your policy or using the mobile app. If you use a shop within Progressive's network, it'll handle the repair process from start to finish and pay the shop directly. You don't have to stick with a shop within Progressive's network, though. If you go to an outside shop, you'll need to provide Progressive with a copy of the repair estimate. Progressive will then issue the payment to you or directly to the shop.
With USAA, you'll need to file a claim online or using the USAA mobile app. You can receive a repair estimate in just four hours if you use the photo estimation tool. If you use a repair shop within USAA's Streamlined Appraisal Repair Service (STARS) network, USAA will coordinate repairs. You'll pay the deductible directly to the auto shop, and USAA will handle the rest of the bill. Most shops within the STARS network also have an Enterprise Rent-a-Car onsite or nearby. If you go outside the STARS network, you'll be responsible for coordinating repairs.
Progressive and USAA both make it easy to shop for a quote, start a claim, or request emergency roadside assistance online via mobile app. Progressive's mobile app and USAA's mobile app each receive an average rating of 4.8 stars on the App Store.
If you need to speak with a human, you can call Progressive customer support 24/7. USAA's customer support is available from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. CT Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. CT Saturdays, and closed on Sundays and major holidays.
Both Progressiveand USAA receive a higher-than-average number of complaints relative to companies of the same size, according to complaint data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). Neither Progressive nor USAA earned top rankings for any region on the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Auto Insurance Study or the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study.
USAA generally offers lower auto insurance rates than Progressive, but membership is limited to members of the military, veterans, and their families. But in some situations, Progressive may have lower rates. For example, drivers with a DUI/DWI generally pay lower rates through Progressive than through USAA, according to data from The Motley Fool Ascent.
Even if you're eligible for USAA membership, it's generally worth comparing quotes. Progressive has several options for customizing your policy, including the Name Your Price Tool, which provides several coverage options depending on how much you want to pay. While it's not quite as easy to customize your policy with USAA, both companies offer competitive driver discounts. If you're open to using a telematics device, you could save even more money by demonstrating safe driving habits.
If you need multiple policies -- for example, auto insurance in addition to a homeowners or renters policy -- it's worth looking at the savings from buying both policies through the same insurer. Progressive and USAA both offer discounts when you bundle policies.
Progressive Rating image, 4.00 out of 5 stars. 4.00/5 Circle with letter I in it.Our ratings are based on a 5 star scale. 5 stars equals Best. 4 stars equals Excellent. 3 stars equals Good. 2 stars equals Fair. 1 star equals Poor. We want your money to work harder for you. Which is why our ratings are biased toward offers that deliver versatility while cutting out-of-pocket costs.
= Best
= Excellent
= Good
= Fair
= Poor
Our ratings are based on a 5 star scale. 5 stars equals Best. 4 stars equals Excellent. 3 stars equals Good. 2 stars equals Fair. 1 star equals Poor. We want your money to work harder for you. Which is why our ratings are biased toward offers that deliver versatility while cutting out-of-pocket costs.
= Best
= Excellent
= Good
= Fair
= Poor
Progressive is a good fit for anyone who wants a wide variety of coverage options and driver discounts, as well as the option to customize coverage based on how much you want to pay. Some high-risk drivers, such as those with a DUI/DWI or another moving violation, may qualify for lower rates with Progressive.
USAA is a strong choice for military members, veterans, and their families. Rates are competitive for most drivers, and USAA offers plenty of driver discounts to lower premiums even further. USAA also offers several discounts for situations unique to military families, such as a discount if you're storing your vehicle while deployed or if you garage your car on a military base.
Share This PageWe're firm believers in the Golden Rule, which is why editorial opinions are ours alone and have not been previously reviewed, approved, or endorsed by included advertisers. The Ascent, a Motley Fool service, does not cover all offers on the market. The Ascent has a dedicated team of editors and analysts focused on personal finance, and they follow the same set of publishing standards and editorial integrity while maintaining professional separation from the analysts and editors on other Motley Fool brands.
Robin Hartill has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Uber Technologies. The Motley Fool recommends Progressive. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
The Ascent is a Motley Fool service that rates and reviews essential products for your everyday money matters.
Copyright © 2018 - 2024 The Ascent. All rights reserved.